Lenovo X1 & X220 im Test: Das Schöne und das Praktische

A2/2

16.7.2011 16:46 Uhr Patrick Bellmer

Messwerte

Getestet wurde mit dem eigens für die Messung von Notebook-Laufzeiten geschriebenen Programm Battery Eater in Version 2.7. Battery Eater erlaubt die Simulation einer Vollast-Situation – CPU und Grafikkarte werden voll ausgelastet – und im sogenannten „Reader's Test“ die Ermittlung der Laufzeit bei geringer Systembelastung. In beiden Fällen wird bei einer Helligkeit von 140 cd/m² gemessen, um mit anderen Geräten vergleichbare Bedingungen zu schaffen. Zusätzlich ist das WLAN-Modul aktiviert.

Akku

Hochleistung (Classic Test):
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  3:04
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  2:36
- Lenovo Thinkpad X201 (Core i5-540M, GMA HD, HDD)
  2:21
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  1:50
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  1:43
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  1:43
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  1:33
  mit AMD 6550M
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i5-450M, GMA HD, SSD)
  1:30
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i3-350M, GMA HD, HDD)
  1:04
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  1:03
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  0:59
Energiesparmodus (Reader's Test):
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:52
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  5:28
  mit Intel GMA HD
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  5:27
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  5:20
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i3-350M, GMA HD, HDD)
  4:46
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  4:45
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i5-450M, GMA HD, SSD)
  4:35
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:48
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  3:20
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  2:57
Praxistest:
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  7:24
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  7:15
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  6:41
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  6:40
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  6:33
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  6:21
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  4:21
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  4:07
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  3:48
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:37
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:15
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  2:25

Einheit: Stunden, Minuten

Die Lautstärke wird in einem Abstand von etwa 50 Zentimetern zum Display gemessen. Diese Position entspricht in der Regel der des Kopfes des Nutzers.

Lautstärke im Vergleich

Leerlauf:
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  28
  Lüfter läuft permanent
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  28
  Lüfter läuft permanent
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  28
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  29
  Lüfter läuft permanent
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  29
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  29
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  30
  Lüfter läuft permanent
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  30
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  30
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  31
  Lüfter läuft permanent
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  32
  Lüfter läuft permanent
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  32
Vollast:
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  34
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  36
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  37
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  40
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  41
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  42
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  43
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  43
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  43
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  43
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  45
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  47
Optisches Laufwerk:
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  41
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  42
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  45
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  45
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  45
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  46
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  47
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  52

Einheit: dB(A)

Für die Messung der Temperaturen unter Last wird das System circa 30 Minuten voll ausgelastet. Um die Leerlaufwerte zu ermitteln, wird das Gerät für ebenfalls etwa 30 Minuten mit möglichst geringer Last (Windows Desktop) belassen. Zum Auslesen der Prozessortemperaturen werden mehrere Programme verwendet, um die Falscherkennung eines einzelnen Tools ausschließen zu können.

Temperatur

Höchster Wert Oberseite, Leerlauf:
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  21,6
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  24,2
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  28,1
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  28,3
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  28,3
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  28,3
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  29,1
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  29,8
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  30,2
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  30,5
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  30,7
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  30,9
Höchster Wert Unterseite, Leerlauf:
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  22,4
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  24,0
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  26,1
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  26,6
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  26,9
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  28,0
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  28,8
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  29,7
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  30,2
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  30,4
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  30,5
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  34,2
Höchster Wert Oberseite, Last:
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  27,8
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  29,3
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  30,0
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  33,9
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  35,2
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  35,7
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  37,4
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  37,8
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  39,0
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  40,2
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  40,5
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  45,8
Höchster Wert Unterseite, Last:
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  30,3
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  31,2
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  31,9
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  33,8
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  34,3
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  34,8
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  35,4
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  36,4
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  40,6
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  43,2
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  43,4
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  43,7
Höchste gemessene Temperatur:
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  38,9
  Blende Luftauslass
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  39,0
  Blende Luftauslass
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  43,1
  Luftauslass
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  44,1
  Blende Luftauslass
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  46,2
  Blende Luftauslass
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  53,4
  Luftauslass
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  55,4
  Blende Luftauslass
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  56,3
  Luftauslass
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  58,2
  Luftauslass
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  65,1
  Luftauslass
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  65,5
  Luftauslass
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  66,2
Prozessor, Leerlauf:
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  35,0
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  39,0
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  40,0
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  40,0
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  40,0
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  40,0
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  44,0
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  55,0
Prozessor, Last:
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  63,0
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  75,0
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  79,0
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  82,0
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  95,0
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  96,0
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  97,0
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  98,0

Einheit: °C

Display

Helligkeit maximal:
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  186
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.100 K
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  206
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.200 K
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  212
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.500 K
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  223
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.800 K
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  257
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.300 K
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i3-350M, GMA HD, HDD)
  260
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.700 K
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  271
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.300 K
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  313
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.400 K
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  321
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.800 K
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD, matt)
  330
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.400 K
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  331
  Weißpunkt ca. 7.100 K
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD, glänzend)
  338
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.400 K
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  358
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.200 K
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  412
  Weißpunkt ca. 6.100 K
Einheit: Leuchtdichte (cd/m²)
Helligkeit minimal:
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  3
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  6
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD, matt)
  7
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  11
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  13
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  15
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  18
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  19
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i3-350M, GMA HD, HDD)
  20
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD, glänzend)
  23
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  25
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  29
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  52
Einheit: Leuchtdichte (cd/m²)
Kontrast:
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  802:1
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  705:1
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD, matt)
  635:1
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD, glänzend)
  626:1
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  577:1
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, Geforce 485M, HDD)
  279:1
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  220:1
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  217:1
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  214:1
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  188:1
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  187:1
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  175:1
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i3-350M, GMA HD, HDD)
  140:1
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  130:1
Einheit: Kontrast