Günstige Notebooks im Test: Samsung, Acer und Packard Bell im Vergleich

A2/3

18.11.2011 19:57 Uhr Patrick Bellmer

Messwerte – Akku, Verbrauch, Lautstärke

Akku

Energiesparmodus (Reader's Test):
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  6:49
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:52
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  5:36
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  5:28
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  5:27
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  5:20
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  5:18
- Dell XPS 15z (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:09
- LG P430 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:04
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  4:51
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i3-350M, GMA HD, HDD)
  4:46
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  4:45
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  4:41
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i5-450M, GMA HD, SSD)
  4:35
- Sony Vaio EH (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  4:35
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  4:31
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  4:19
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  4:19
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:48
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  3:20
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, GeForce 485M, HDD)
  2:57
Hochleistung (Classic Test):
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  5:08
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  3:08
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  3:04
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  2:52
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  2:49
- LG P430 (Core i5-2520M, Nvidia GT 520M, HDD)
  2:42
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  2:36
- Lenovo Thinkpad X201 (Core i5-540M, GMA HD, HDD)
  2:21
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Nvidia NVS 4200M, HDD)
  2:15
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  1:50
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, GeForce 485M, HDD)
  1:43
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  1:43
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  1:41
- Dell XPS 15z (Core i7-2620M, Nvidia GT 525M, HDD)
  1:36
- Sony Vaio EH (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  1:34
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  1:33
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  1:31
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i5-450M, GMA HD, SSD)
  1:30
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  1:27
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  1:24
- HP ProBook 5320m (Core i3-350M, GMA HD, HDD)
  1:04
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  1:03
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  0:59
Praxistest:
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  7:24
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  7:15
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  7:14
- Apple MacBook Air 2011 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000 SSD)
  6:52
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  6:41
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  6:40
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  6:33
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  6:21
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  6:17
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  6:02
- Dell XPS 15z (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:46
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  5:37
- LG P430 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:37
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  5:21
- Sony Vaio EH (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:20
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:16
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  5:13
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  5:02
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  4:21
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  4:07
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  3:48
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:37
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:15
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, GeForce 485M, HDD)
  2:25

Einheit: Stunden, Minuten

Ermittelt wird der Verbrauch mit einem entsprechenden Messgerät. Dieses erfasst Verbräuche ab 0,05 Watt, die Abweichung beträgt +/- fünf Prozent. Gemessen wird im Standby, im Leerlaufbetrieb (Desktop) und unter Volllast. In letzterem Fall wird die gleiche Situation genutzt, die auch bei der Messung der Temperaturen unter Last verwendet wird. Die Werte stellen aber lediglich die Spitzen in der jeweiligen Situation dar.

Verbrauch Notebooks

Standby:
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  0,4
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,4
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  0,4
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  0,6
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  0,7
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  0,7
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  0,7
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  0,7
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  0,7
Leerlauf, 140 cd:
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  10,0
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  10,2
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  12,9
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  13,5
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  13,9
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  14,8
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  15,4
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  18,9
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  23,5
Volllast, 140 cd:
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  17,6
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  18,9
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  21,3
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  42,2
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  45,7
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  47,1
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  58,3
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  62,3
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Nvidia NVS 4200M, HDD)
  78,1
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  84,9
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6750M, HDD)
  86,1
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6755G2, HDD)
  95,1

Einheit: Watt (W)

Die Lautstärke wird in einem Abstand von etwa 50 Zentimetern zum Display gemessen. Diese Position entspricht in der Regel der des Kopfes des Nutzers.

Lautstärke im Vergleich

Leerlauf:
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  28
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  28
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  28
- Sony Vaio EH (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  28
- Apple MacBook Air 2011 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000 SSD)
  28
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  28
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  29
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  29
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  29
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  29
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  29
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  30
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  30
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  30
- LG P430 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  30
- Dell XPS 15z (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  30
- Apple Mac Mini 2011 (Core i5-2410M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  30
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  30
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  30
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  31
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  31
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  31
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  31
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  32
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, GeForce 485M, HDD)
  32
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  40
Vollast:
- Apple Mac Mini 2011 (Core i5-2410M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  33
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  34
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  36
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  37
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  38
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  39
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  40
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Nvidia NVS 4200M, HDD)
  40
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  41
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  42
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6755G2, HDD)
  42
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  42
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  43
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  43
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  43
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, GeForce 485M, HDD)
  43
- Sony Vaio EH (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  43
- LG P430 (Core i5-2520M, Nvidia GT 520M, HDD)
  43
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  43
- Samsung NC110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  43
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  43
- Apple MacBook Air 2011 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000 SSD)
  44
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  45
- Dell XPS 15z (Core i7-2620M, Nvidia GT 525M, HDD)
  46
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  46
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  47
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  49
Optisches Laufwerk:
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  41
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  42
- Sony Vaio EH (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  43
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  43
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  44
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  45
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  45
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, GeForce 485M, HDD)
  45
- LG P430 (Core i5-2520M, Nvidia GT 520M, HDD)
  45
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  45
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  46
- Dell XPS 15z (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  46
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  46
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  46
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  47
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  49
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  52

Einheit: dB(A)