Apple MacBook im Test: Air und Pro mit 13 Zoll im Vergleich

A5/6

19.6.2012 15:50 Uhr Patrick Bellmer

Akku & Verbrauch

Ermittelt wird der Verbrauch mit einem entsprechenden Messgerät. Dieses erfasst Verbräuche ab 0,05 Watt, die Abweichung beträgt +/- fünf Prozent. Gemessen wird im Standby, im Leerlaufbetrieb (Desktop) und unter Volllast. In letzterem Fall wird die gleiche Situation genutzt, die auch bei der Messung der Temperaturen unter Last verwendet wird. Die Werte stellen aber lediglich die Spitzen in der jeweiligen Situation dar.

Verbrauch Notebooks

Standby:
- Apple MacBook Air 13" 2012 (i5-3427U, HD 4000, SSD)
  0,3
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  0,4
- Samsung 530U3B (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  0,4
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,4
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  0,4
- Asus N76VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  0,4
- Asus N56VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  0,4
- Acer Aspire M3 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  0,4
- Apple MacBook Pro 13" 2012 (i5-3210M, HD 4000, HDD)
  0,5
- Asus X53SK (Core i5-2450M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  0,5
- Asus Zenbook UX31E (Core i7-2667M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,5
- Asus Zenbook UX21E (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,6
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  0,6
- HP Folio 13 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,6
- One M56-2O (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  0,6
- Samsung NC-110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  0,7
- Samsung T700T1A (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,7
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  0,7
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  0,7
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  0,7
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  0,7
- Asus K75D (A8-4500M, HD 7640G, HDD)
  0,7
- Dell XPS 13 (Core i7-2637M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,7
- HP Envy 14 Spectre (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,7
- Toshiba Satellite Z830 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  0,8
- One M56-2N (i7-3820QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  0,8
- Dell XPS 14z (Core i5-2430M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  0,8
- One M56-2N (i7-2960XM, Intel HD 3000, SSD/HDD)
  0,8
- Acer Aspire S3 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  1,3
Leerlauf, 140 cd:
- Apple MacBook Air 13" 2012 (i5-3427U, HD 4000, SSD)
  9,1
- Apple MacBook Pro 13" 2012 (i5-3210M, HD 4000, HDD)
  9,7
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  10,0
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  10,2
- Toshiba Satellite Z830 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  10,8
- Acer Aspire S3 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  11,5
- HP Envy 14 Spectre (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  12,7
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  12,9
- HP Folio 13 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  12,9
- Acer Aspire M3 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  13,1
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  13,5
- Samsung NC-110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  13,9
- Asus Zenbook UX21E (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  14,5
- Samsung T700T1A (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  14,6
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  14,8
- Samsung 530U3B (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  15,1
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  15,4
- Asus Zenbook UX31E (Core i7-2667M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  16,8
- Dell XPS 14z (Core i5-2430M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  18,2
- Asus N56VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  18,3
- One M56-2N (i7-3820QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  18,4
- One M56-2O (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  18,8
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  18,9
- Asus X53SK (Core i5-2450M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  19,1
- Asus X53SK (Core i5-2450M, HD 7610M, HDD)
  21,2
- Dell XPS 13 (Core i7-2637M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  21,2
- Asus N76VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  22,3
- Asus K75D (A8-4500M, HD 7640G, HDD)
  22,3
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  23,5
- One M56-2N (i7-2960XM, Intel HD 3000, SSD/HDD)
  26,0
Volllast, 140 cd:
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  17,6
- Samsung NC-110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  18,9
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  21,3
- HP Folio 13 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  32,3
- Asus Zenbook UX21E (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  33,0
- Dell XPS 13 (Core i7-2637M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  33,1
- HP Envy 14 Spectre (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  33,2
- Toshiba Satellite Z830 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  33,5
- Samsung T700T1A (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  35,6
- Asus X53SK (Core i5-2450M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  36,1
- Samsung 530U3B (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  36,1
- Acer Aspire S3 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  36,8
- Apple MacBook Air 13" 2012 (i5-3427U, HD 4000, SSD)
  37,4
- Asus Zenbook UX31E (Core i7-2667M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  38,1
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  42,2
- Asus K75D (A8-4500M, HD 7640G, HDD)
  42,3
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  45,7
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  47,1
- Asus X53SK (Core i5-2450M, HD 7610M, HDD)
  47,8
- Dell XPS 14z (Core i5-2430M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  49,2
- Apple MacBook Pro 13" 2012 (i5-3210M, HD 4000, HDD)
  49,8
- One M56-2O (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  57,6
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  58,3
- Acer Aspire M3 (Core i5-2467M, GT 640M, HDD)
  60,5
- Asus N56VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  61,2
- Asus N76VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  61,8
- Asus K75D (A8-4500M, HD 7640G & HD 7670M, HDD)
  62,1
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  62,3
- Asus K75D (A8-4500M, HD 7670M, HDD)
  68,8
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Nvidia NVS 4200M, HDD)
  78,1
- One M56-2N (i7-3820QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  82,4
- One M56-2O (i7-3610QM, GT 650M, SSD/HDD)
  84,4
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, HD 6650M, SSD)
  84,9
- One M56-2N (i7-2960XM, Intel HD 3000, SSD/HDD)
  85,2
- Asus N56VM (i7-3610QM, GT 630M, HDD)
  85,3
- Asus N76VM (i7-3610QM, GT 630M, HDD)
  86,0
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6750M, HDD)
  86,1
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6755G2, HDD)
  95,1
- One M56-2N (i7-3820QM, GTX 670M, SSD/HDD)
  106,3
- One M56-2N (i7-2960XM, GTX 670M, SSD/HDD)
  108,7

Einheit: Watt (W)

Für das Ermitteln der Akkulaufzeit im Leerlauf und unter Last verwenden wir Battery Eater bei einer Bildschirmhelligkeit von 140 Candela pro Quadratmeter sowie aktiviertem WLAN. Im Leerlauf wird dabei das Leser eines Dokuments simuliert, unter Last werden alle wichtige Komponenten einbezogen. Im Praxistest wird das Gerät zum Surfen im Internet sowie zum Schreiben verwendet. Hinzu kommen mehrere Phasen des Leerlaufs, in denen der Bildschirmschoner nach zehn Minuten, die Bildschirmabschaltung nach 15 Minuten aktiviert wird.

Akku

Praxistest:
- Apple MacBook Air 13" 2012 (i5-3427U, HD 4000, SSD)
  7:49
- Apple MacBook Air 2010 (C2D SL9400, GeForce 320M, SSD)
  7:24
- Samsung 900X3A (Core i5-2537M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  7:15
- Samsung NC-110 (Atom N455, Intel GMA 3150, HDD)
  7:14
- Apple MacBook Air 2011 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000 SSD)
  6:52
- Apple MacBook Pro 13" 2012 (i5-3210M, HD 4000, HDD)
  6:51
- Lenovo X220 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  6:41
- Apple MacBook Pro 17" 2011 (Core i7-2720QM, HD 6750M, HDD)
  6:40
- Acer Aspire Timeline X 5820TG (Core i5-480M, HD 6550M, HDD)
  6:33
- HP Folio 13 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  6:32
- Apple MacBook Pro 15" 2011 (Core i7-2635QM, HD 6490M, HDD)
  6:21
- Dell XPS 13 (Core i7-2637M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  6:18
- PB Butterfly XS (Pentium SU4100, Intel GMA 4500MHD, HDD)
  6:17
- One M56-2N (i7-2960XM, Intel HD 3000, SSD/HDD)
  6:15
- HP Envy 14 Spectre (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  6:14
- One M56-2N (i7-3820QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  6:06
- Sony Vaio Z21 (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  6:02
- Asus X53SK (Core i5-2450M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:49
- Dell XPS 15z (Core i7-2620M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:46
- Asus N56VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  5:42
- Samsung 530U3B (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:39
- Acer Aspire one 522 (C-60, HD 6290, HDD)
  5:37
- LG P430 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:37
- Asus Zenbook UX31E (Core i7-2667M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  5:25
- Dell Vostro 3555 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  5:21
- Sony Vaio EH (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:20
- Samsung 200B5B (Core i3-2310M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:16
- Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E525 (A8-3500M, HD 6620G, HDD)
  5:13
- Toshiba Satellite Z830 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  5:05
- Asus X53SK (Core i5-2450M, HD 7610M, HDD)
  5:04
- HP Pavilion dv6-6110sg (A6-3410MX, HD 6520G, HDD)
  5:02
- Dell XPS 14z (Core i5-2430M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  5:02
- One M56-2O (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, SSD/HDD)
  5:01
- Acer Aspire M3 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  4:45
- Asus N76VM (i7-3610QM, Intel HD 4000, HDD)
  4:36
- Lenovo X1 (Core i5-2520M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  4:21
- Samsung T700T1A (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  4:13
- Asus Zenbook UX21E (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, SSD)
  4:08
- Acer Aspire 5253 (AMD E-350, HD 6310M, HDD)
  4:07
- Acer Aspire S3 (Core i5-2467M, Intel HD 3000, HDD)
  4:00
- Sony Vaio SB (Core i5-2410M, HD 6470M, HDD)
  3:48
- Schenker XMG A701 (Core i7-2630QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:37
- Asus N53SV (Core i7-2720QM, GeForce 540M, HDD)
  3:15
- Schenker XMG P501 Pro (Core i5-2410M, GeForce 485M, HDD)
  2:25